Steve and Brenda Foley were first presented to TLC fans on season 4 of Seeking Sister Wife. Numerous red flags have marked their time on the show.
Steve And Brenda Foley’s TLC Story
Season 4 of Seeking Sister Wife on TLC featured Steve and Brenda Foley as one of three new polygamous couples, and viewers were quick to bring out some big red flags about the duo. The Texas-based couple spoke up to viewers about their hunt for a sister wife over several years, hoping to bring April into their already-complicated family dynamic.
Fans Point Out The Red Flags In Steve and Brenda Foley’s Relationship
Brenda feels left out after Steve and his potential sister wife, April, hit it off so quickly on Seeking Sister Wife Season 4, even though both Steve and Brenda were eager to expand their family. Brenda fears her importance to Steve and April diminishes as they spend more time together. Brenda remained concerned about the blossoming relationship between Steve and April throughout their stay on the show.
She thinks Steve and April are moving too quickly after Steve (who has 1392 Instagram followers) admitted his feelings for April early in their relationship. Fan reactions to Steve and Brenda have been mixed over their brief time on the show. Here are some huge red flags from the family Seeking Sister Wife, ranging from their history with Steve’s previous wife to their connections with Steve’s family.
Steve had married his sweetheart during high school and had two children with her before he met and started seeing Brenda. He and his ex-wife shared a 12-year monogamous marriage before he met and fell in love with Brenda. It wasn’t long after Steve and his first wife met Brenda before they decided to make their relationship polygamous and bring Brenda in as a second-sister wife.
Rapidly ending her polygamous relationship with Seeking Sister Wife Steve and Brenda Foley, she departed the couple. Steve and Brenda claim that his previous wife filed for divorce due to the overwhelming backlash from their friends and family, even though the relationship had a good start.
Viewers on Reddit, though, suspect that there’s more to the series than Steve and Brenda are letting on. “Steve let his first wife, the mother of his children, leave because she stopped being into his 2 woman ideal,” one Redditor wrote. The fourth episode of Seeking Sister Wife’s fourth season aired on July 4, giving viewers a glimpse into the delicate relationship Steve and Brenda have with Steve’s children, Preston, 18, and Jayden, 16.
Taking a break from their pursuit of April, a potential sister bride, Steve, and Brenda traveled to Dallas, Texas, to spend time with his kids. During this visit, Steve told his kids about his developing relationship with April. His daughter Jayden did not approve of their practice of Seeking Sister Wife polygamy and made her feelings known. “It’s weird for your parents to date multiple people.
Because I think when you become a parent, those relationships and activities should not be a thing,” Jayden said during the show. Jayden also stated, “That’s a decision he should’ve thought of before he had two kids. I genuinely think his lifestyle is disgusting. It’s gross.” Season 4 of Seeking Sister Wife follows Brenda and Steve as they embark on a new journey.
They are currently looking for a potential new sister’s wife. They’ve started seeing a young lady named April; she’s 21 and unique to the Seeking Sister Wife movement. Many viewers have voiced their concern over Steve and Brenda, at ages 42 and 38 respectively, are far older (and more accustomed to polygamy) than their future sister wife, April.
Another commenter remarked that Brenda, April, and Steve “looked like they were having dinner with their daughter from college home from school” that evening. Numerous viewers have observed that the already wide age gap between Steve and Brenda and April is emphasized because April is younger than both Steve’s children and Brenda.

